By Jeremy Nelson, LPCC-S | Dayton Anxiety Counseling & Consultation
In my work as a therapist, I am often surprised by how many people struggle to explain what anxiety actually is. Most people can describe what anxiety feels like. They can tell you about the racing thoughts, tightness in their chest, restless nights, or overwhelming sense that something is wrong. But when I ask them to define anxiety itself, the answer becomes harder to describe.
Sometimes people get close, but they often describe something more closely related to fear or stress.
We generally understand fear. Fear is that raw, instinctive response that grabs our attention when we perceive danger. It is an important part of our biological makeup, alerting us to potential threats and preparing us to respond. Our brains and nervous systems constantly evaluate the world around us, prioritizing information that might matter to our safety or well-being. Sometimes these systems activate before we are even consciously aware of what happened.
Stress is another familiar experience. It has become something of a buzzword over the past several decades. We know stress affects us physically, hormonally, cognitively, and emotionally. We can feel it in our bodies. Stress often arises when the demands placed upon us exceed, or seem to exceed, our available resources.
Over time, however, I think we have begun to conflate these experiences with anxiety itself.
Feeling afraid, experiencing stress, or having an uncomfortable physiological response does not necessarily explain the psychological process we call anxiety.
The American Psychological Association's Dictionary of Psychology describes anxiety as an emotion involving apprehension and physical tension associated with anticipating possible danger or misfortune.
I don't necessarily disagree with that description of the experience. However, after years of working with people struggling with anxiety and obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), I have come to think about anxiety somewhat differently.
My working definition is simpler: Anxiety often emerges from our attempts to control what cannot be controlled.
When an Experience Becomes a Problem
Imagine noticing your heart beating rapidly. Perhaps you have been exercising, drinking too much caffeine, or experiencing an unexpected surge of adrenaline. The sensation itself is not necessarily dangerous. Your body may be doing exactly what it was designed to do.
But what happens when you notice the sensation and begin to judge it?
Why is my heart beating so fast? What if something is wrong? I shouldn't be feeling this way. How do I make it stop?
Something important has changed. The person is no longer simply experiencing an elevated heart rate. They have evaluated the sensation as problematic and begun attempting to control it. They might monitor their pulse, search for symptoms online, seek reassurance, or attempt to force their body to calm down. When those attempts fail to provide lasting certainty or relief, the struggle continues.
This is where I believe anxiety begins to take shape.
The initial sensation was an experience. The judgment that something was wrong, followed by the perceived need to control it, created an entirely different relationship with that experience. This process is not always deliberate or conscious. Our judgments and responses can become so automatic that we scarcely recognize them as separate events.
We simply say, "I feel anxious."
But what if much of the anxiety we experience is the struggle we have developed against an initial feeling or possibility?
Concern Versus Control-Oriented Worry
I find it helpful to distinguish between two ways we respond to problems and uncertainty. Psychologist Adrian Wells (1995) explored how beliefs about worry and attempts to control worrying can help maintain generalized anxiety disorder. The distinction I use in my clinical work is somewhat different: productive concern versus control-oriented, ruminative worry.
Concern is a healthy and necessary part of being human. It allows us to recognize problems, evaluate evidence, anticipate reasonable consequences, and respond appropriately. If I notice that my car tires are becoming worn, I might become concerned about driving safely. That concern leads me to inspect the tires and replace them when needed. The concern has served its purpose. I identified a problem, considered the evidence, and took reasonable action.
Control-oriented worry is different.
Instead of helping us reach a reasonable solution, it becomes a repetitive attempt to eliminate uncertainty, prevent every unwanted outcome, or gain control over something that cannot be fully controlled.
Consider the same tires. I might replace all four but continue worrying about whether they were installed correctly. I might repeatedly inspect them, research tire failures, or mentally review everything that could go wrong while driving. At some point, thinking is no longer helping me solve a problem. It is temporarily helping me escape the discomfort of uncertainty.
And because complete certainty is rarely possible, there is no satisfying endpoint.
This distinction matters because the content of our worry does not necessarily tell us whether it is helpful. A person can have legitimate concerns about health, finances, marriage, or children and still develop an unhealthy relationship with those concerns.
The difference is not simply what we are thinking about, but what we are attempting to accomplish through our thinking. Productive concern helps us respond to life. Ruminative worry attempts to make life certain.
The Illusion of Control
One of the clearest examples of this distinction is our relationship with technology. We live in a world with unprecedented access to information. We can monitor our health, track our children, receive immediate updates about events across the world, and search for answers to almost any question within seconds.
One might reasonably expect that more information would make us less anxious. Shouldn't greater awareness and the ability to anticipate potential dangers help us feel safer?
In many ways, technology genuinely has made our lives safer. We can contact emergency services, identify dangerous weather, navigate unfamiliar places, and monitor medical conditions more effectively than previous generations. But there is a difference between having more information and having greater control over the outcomes we fear.
Consider a parent whose child is at school. Thirty years ago, that parent might have dropped their child off in the morning and trusted that everything would be fine until they returned home. Today, that parent might have a GPS tracker attached to the child's backpack.
At any moment, the parent can pull out a phone and see that the backpack is still at school.
But what has actually changed?
The parent has more information about the location of the backpack. That may occasionally be useful, but it does not necessarily provide greater control over the child's safety. The parent still cannot prevent every accident, illness, injury, or unexpected event. Yet the ability to check can create a powerful sense of reassurance.
And reassurance can become something we depend upon. What starts as a convenient way to obtain information can gradually become a behavior we feel compelled to perform whenever uncertainty arises.
We check because we feel uncomfortable. Checking reduces that discomfort for a while. Eventually, uncertainty creates another urge to check. Without recognizing it, we may begin teaching ourselves that uncertainty is something we should not have to tolerate.
Technology has dramatically expanded our ability to monitor our lives, but it has not necessarily expanded our ability to control them.
In some circumstances, it may reinforce the illusion that enough information will eventually eliminate uncertainty.
Human beings possess an extraordinary ability to anticipate the future. We can imagine possibilities, identify dangers, prepare for challenges, and develop solutions to problems that have not yet occurred. This ability has contributed enormously to our survival and success. But it creates an interesting predicament: Our ability to imagine what might happen is far greater than our ability to control what actually happens.
We can imagine our children getting hurt, losing someone we love, developing a serious illness, failing professionally, or being rejected by others. We can imagine thousands of possible futures, but we cannot guarantee which one will occur.
When we treat every unwanted possibility as a problem that must be resolved, our minds can become consumed with an impossible task. We try to think our way into certainty. We review conversations, anticipate disasters, seek reassurance, avoid uncomfortable experiences, and monitor the world around us for signs that something might go wrong.
These behaviors can provide temporary relief, but often at a cost. The more we rely on control to manage uncertainty, the more threatening uncertainty can begin to feel. And the more threatening it feels, the more urgently we seek control.
Learning a Different Relationship With Anxiety
If anxiety is understood only as an unpleasant emotional or physiological experience, it makes sense that people would spend much of their time trying to eliminate those feelings.
They want to feel calmer, think more positively, and stop experiencing uncomfortable sensations. Those goals are understandable. But what if trying to eliminate those experiences is sometimes the very thing keeping them trapped?
This is one reason I value approaches such as Exposure and Response Prevention (ERP) and Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT).
Rather than insisting that people eliminate fear, uncertainty, or uncomfortable sensations before moving forward, these approaches help people develop a different relationship with those experiences. A person can:
Experience an intrusive thought without needing to resolve it.
Notice an uncomfortable sensation without immediately trying to change it.
Recognize that something unwanted might happen without organizing their entire life around preventing that possibility.
This does not mean abandoning reasonable precautions, ignoring legitimate problems, or accepting circumstances that can and should be changed. It means learning to distinguish between what requires a meaningful response and what requires a willingness to experience uncertainty.
There are many things in life we can influence, improve, prevent, or change. There are also things we cannot. The difficulty arises when we become unwilling to recognize the difference.
Few expressions capture this balance between acceptance and change as simply as the Serenity Prayer, commonly associated with Alcoholics Anonymous and generally attributed to theologian Reinhold Niebuhr:
God grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, courage to change the things I can, and wisdom to know the difference.
Perhaps our greatest problem with anxiety is not simply that our brains and bodies are too sensitive to potential threats. Perhaps it is that we have become increasingly convinced that we should be able to control the thoughts, feelings, sensations, and outcomes that accompany being human.
And perhaps the solution is not found in obtaining more information, greater reassurance, or perfect control.
Perhaps freedom from anxiety begins when we stop treating every uncomfortable experience and uncertain possibility as a problem that must be solved, or even can be solved.
Jeremy Nelson, LPCC-S, provides evidence-based treatment for anxiety and OCD at Dayton Anxiety Counseling & Consultation in Dayton, Ohio.
References
American Psychological Association. (n.d.). Anxiety. In APA dictionary of psychology. https://dictionary.apa.org/anxiety
Wells, A. (1995). Meta-cognition and worry: A cognitive model of generalized anxiety disorder. Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy, 23(3), 301–320. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1352465800015897
Serenity Prayer attribution: Alcoholics Anonymous, “Origin of the Serenity Prayer: A Historical Paper.”
